Homemade "Clean" Marshmallows

When I first found out about my daughter's food sensitivity, I scrambled to try to make all the foods and snacks she loved in a homemade version. Through trial and error (lots and lots of error) I was able to make almost everything. But marshmallows, marshmallows were the bane of my existence. I just could not get them right. I couldn't find any organic versions without natural flavors or corn syrup in them. I made homemade versions using agar-agar and almost gagged at the grainy, sea watery flavor. I got marshmallow string in my hair, on my kitchen floor and everywhere. I had flat marshmallows and gray marshmallows. I gave up. I admitted defeat.

And for most people, what's the big deal about marshmallows anyway? They taste kinda' gross, they're sticky and gelatinous and they were definitely not one of my favorite foods. Now caramel, that's another issue altogether, but I digress. For a camping family, marshmallows and s'mores are such a huge part of the campfire traditions. I tried to compensate. I made other desserts to have around the campfire. We loved our mini apple and cherry pies. We loved our Dutch Oven brownies. But we did miss roasting our marshmallows. And we missed s'mores. So I kept at it.

I tweaked a few homemade recipes and finally, FINALLY...sweet success. Marshmallows are (relatively) easy! And delicious. I even love these marshmallows! Victory is SWEET!!!

Homemade Marshmallows
2 tablespoons Gelatin (we use Great Lakes Unflavored Gelatin)
8 tablespoons cold water
2 cups granulated sugar
1/2 cold water
1/4 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons pure vanilla
At least one bag of powdered sugar to dust pan and help dry the marshmallows out.

1. With Marshmallows, preparation is KEY!! Get all of your things ready ahead of time, before you have a sticky mess ready ahead of time. 
2. Line a baking dish with parchment paper. Then sprinkle lots and lots of powdered sugar in bottom of pan. Try to dust sides with powdered sugar, but it will fall down, don't stress about it, just do your best. 
3. Put gelatin in a small bowl, add 8 tbs of water to bowl. Mix, and set aside so gelatin can firm up. 
4. In a medium saucepan, combine 2 cups granulated sugar and 1/2 cup cold water. Stir.
5. Heat and stir mixture over medium heat until the sugar is dissolved. 
6. Add the gelatin mixture to the saucepan and stir. Bring to a boil. 
7. When mixture boils, remove it from the heat. 
8. Pour into the bowl of your Kitchenaid mixer (or another large bowl) and allow to cool off a bit.
9. Add salt and vanilla.
10. Cooling will take quite a while, but when the liquid is just slightly warm (you will be able to touch the sides of the bowl without burning yourself), it's ready to mix.
11. Beat with your mixer until the clear-ish mixture becomes light and fluffy peaks (like marshmallow creme). It will double in size in your bowl. 
12. Pour and use a spatula to spread the marshmallow mixture into the parchment, powdered sugar covered pan, and smooth out as much as possible. You can bang the pan on the counter a few times until it's mostly even in the pan. Sprinkle powdered sugar on the top of the marshmallows. 
13. Now you wait. You can put the pan of marshmallow somewhere where it won't be touched until they can dry. Leave the top uncovered. You want it to dry out. 
14. After several hours, you can remove the parchment paper and marshmallows from the pan and lay it on the counter. Try to peel the sides of paper down and sprinkle more powdered sugar on the sides of the marshmallow. The sugar helps the marshmallow dry out more, and also keeps it from sticking. 
15. After a few more hours (or the next day) you can use a sharp knife to cut the marshmallows into squares. You can make large squares for roasting, or smaller ones, for mini marshmallows. You may need to dust the marshmallows with more powdered sugar so you can cut them more easily. 
16. Sprinkle marshmallows liberally with powdered sugar. Place them in bag or glass jar for storage. I store ours in the freezer and just pull them out as needed. 

Batch on the left shows the marshmallows after they've been partially whipped. Batch on the right shows the cooling marshmallow liquid prior to whipping.
My critics love it!

This shows the marshmallows just poured into the parchment covered pans. I've powder-sugared the pans and am allowing the marshmallows to dry out. The marshmallows with sprinkles are a peppermint batch I made over Christmas break. 
 Our family is back in business. We are a marshmallow-toasting-s'more-making family once again!





Popular posts from this blog

Car Seats in an RV?

Bike Riding with three small children

California State Park Camping Reservations-Big Changes Coming Soon!